Showing posts with label Alvin Plantinga. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Alvin Plantinga. Show all posts

Sunday, August 17, 2008

Plantinga Argument Against Naturalism

Plantinga argues: "the probability that our minds are reliable under a conjunction of naturalism and evolution is low or inscrutable. Therefore, to assert that naturalistic evolution is true also asserts that one has a low or unknown probability of being right."

So, if naturalistic evolution is true, then Plantinga's mind is not reliable. He has a low probability of being right about anything.

Therefore, we should reject his argument, as it is most probably wrong.